So the new Red Hot Chili Peppers album has arrived at last, a mere 5 short years after the double disc Stadium Arcadium. Everyone has been clamoring for my review, dying to know if I would give it the coveted pass or the dreaded fail. Certainly, my review being held in such high regard – many a past album’s success or failure has hinged upon my recommendation or lack thereof – is a responsibility I take very seriously. For that reason this review is a tad verbose but not nearly as much as it could have been (been pronounced Canadian style like “bean” because I like the sound of that better). I’ll spare the history lesson for the time being because I’m certain that will come at a later date. The Chili Peppers were my favorite band for many years and there was a time when my love for them was so intense I would have jumped into a tank of great white sharks wearing a chum tuxedo if they had asked. My love for this band continues – that shall never change - but I have since found many other artists to take their place or higher in some cases. Despite this I’d be lying if I said this wasn’t one of my most anticipated music releases of the year, made even more interesting by the addition of new guitarist Josh Klinghoffer. Truly, this is a time of renaissance for these merry gentlemen and they sound inspired. But inspiration does not always cut through the way it should. Are the incandescent hooks still present? What about the sly and persistent riffs? And how about the thick and juicy bass licks, are those still on display? Read on dear followers, read on and all shall be revealed….
Monarchy of Roses kicks things off on a truly inspired note. The verses call to mind Warped from the underrated One Hot Minute though I’m sure if one were to ask the band about this they would say something like "Those two songs have a definite spirit about them but do not co-mingle at all, they are each their own color, their own shade in the Chili Peppers rainbow" and I suppose they would be right, that is simply what the verses bring to my brain. We have AK using a wacky vocal effect which cheeses some people off to no end while others grin enthusiastically while still others stand by with no discernible emotional reaction since they barely notice. I dig the effect, it sounds down and dirty and gritty [much like Frank Miller’s seminal comic book classic The Dark Knight Returns (actually, this humble writer always preferred Year One to DKR but I can’t deny it’s influence)]. Yes, it’s a real grimy sound and it suits his voice and I’m listening and thinking okay, this is a nice track. But then...wait...DAMN...the dynamics of this song are intense and it’s a cool wash of relief to hear dynamics in their songs again (though they kind of leave after this one but more on that later). The chorus erupts like discofied volcano, spewing funky yet melodic hot lava all over the damn place. Seriously, that chorus is epic and sounds great blowing out the car speakers when one is driving at night (Warlocks from Stadium Arcadium works well for this too). Kiedis’s lyrics sound interesting though I have not delved too deeply into them for this particular song. With this track I must take a moment to talk about the lip smacking new guitarist - The Condiment King himself - Mr. Josh Klinghoffer. Any doubts I may have had were to put to rest when we get to that strange wonderful solo like moment around halfway through the song. You know what I’m talking about (statement, not question). It sounds like two angry ambient monsters are battling it out for control of some new musical metropolis. It is a spectacular moment and I believe not something Frusciante ever would have done on a Chili Peppers record. Now hang on there devoted followers of the Fru, before you lynch me I’m not at all saying he COULDN’T play something like that, of course he could. I’m simply saying it’s completely different from the solos and such he would put on their albums. That difference means this song is not only kick-arse but also a huge breath of fresh air, always good with a band. We chorus out and I conclude that this a great opener and indeed a great song.
Factory of Faith: We start off with a butt-munchingly good bass line (this album is full of them, I haven’t been able to sit down all week) and this is countered by Kiedis’s snarky delivery. Flea and drummer Chad Smith are locked into a liquid-tight groove which lets Josh fill in the blanks and throw in some interesting effects in the coda. This is an infectious little number and though I at first thought it was a bit too slight I now think it is one of the weirdly essential songs here. I like to put this song on while I perform my morning routine of shower, shave and self-loath – briefly contemplating suicide by razor to the jugular before resigning myself to one more day, just one more day. It usually cheers me up so it must be doing something right.
Brendan’s Death Song: Beautiful. We start off with an elegant acoustic guitar that is so wonderfully straightforward and unassuming; it’s like a sweet and gentle gaze by a beautiful stranger from across the bar. So many folk think things need to be avante garde (sic)and abstract or Shred City when it comes to guitar (incidentally, the one trip I took to Shred City ended with me waking up in the middle of an alley and then promptly stripped naked, tarred and feathered, you can bet I won’t be making a return trip back there any time soon). Truth be told, I love weird stuff (for instance, I’m very attracted to Beatrice Dalle’s brutal and merciless killer from the great contemporary French horror classic A’ l’interieur or Inside for us Americans) but sometimes it is the simple and melodic that can be so much more powerful. AK’s melody is surprisingly lovely as well. You can hear the mourning and passion in his voice as he recites his eulogy like lyrics. The song gets rather intense halfway through with a psychotic burst of drumming from Smith but this too underscores the loss described here. Anthony’s plaintive wails at the end are another welcome surprise and show the continued marked improvement in his singing.
Ethiopia: My beloved friend Willem Joseph Montejamo sited (or cited if you prefer) this as his favorite song of the new disc. Now, I hold Willem Joseph’s opinion in the utmost regard but music is rarely something we see eye to eye on (especially that time he tried to convince me that U2 is just a poor man’s Coldplay, haha, what a crazy loon that W.J.). This song is also not something we see eye to eye on. I must admit that I did not particularly care for this song at first. Anthony’s repeated E I O I E A reminded a little too much of that old jazz standard Old McDonald’s Farm, and then the chorus melody sounds like a direct copy of the one in Dani California (at least to my lamebrain). But everyone else seems to love this song so I decided to be a happy conformist and jump on the bandwagon too. No, I’m just kidding. I don’t love this one but it is starting to grow on me like an untended fungus - particularly after seeing a live version of it on their recent theatrically released concert. The bass is succulent and solid and Chad rocks as hard as ever - Chad actually rocks throughout this entire disc - but other than that I still haven’t found much to be excited about here. The track just seems to go by before I even realize it’s playing. Oh well, I’ll remain in the spat upon minority.
Annie Wants a Baby: Immediately the bass line reminds me of This Is The Place, excellent song from the excellent By the Way. But other than that this tune is completely different. I would call this the real sleeper of the album, the creeper, the daydreamer and the non-powdered dairy creamer. This song doesn’t reach out and slap you across the face but simply caresses your shoulder – that stranger from the bar inching ever closer. The vocals and guitar melt into one another and the effect is lovely. That said, this song might be a little too subtle for it’s own good and I start to nod off in the middle of it….
Look Around: Yes! Just when I think this album is hitting a dry patch along comes this song to properly lubricate things all over again. At last! This track is really funk on a stick classic Chili Peppers reflected through the technicolor prism of a glorious new age of Red Hot musical evolution (seriously Rolling Stone Magazine, give me a call and for the right price, this glorious prose can grace your pages as well). AK fills the song with his usual nonsense lyrics about stuff and things but it doesn’t get on my nerves this time around because I’m too wrapped in the bone-crunching beat. I usually don’t like the AC-DC style of chorus whereby the singer simply repeats a meaningless bumper sticker phrase 6,285 times over a power chord background but the momentum is so strong here that I find myself singing along with him and pounding my chest like a rabid ape. Anthony’s breakdown sounds an awful lot like the breakdown in By the Way but that’s okay too and the sexy harmonizing he and J.K. do at the end sends me spiraling across my room in a bold spurt of suggestive interpretive dance. I love this song so much that if it were a breakfast cereal I would have two bowls of it for breakfast, even going so far as to include sliced bananas and raspberries and not brushing my teeth afterward so the taste would linger through the day. A real highlight.
The Adventures of Raindance Maggie: This was quite a divisive first single wasn’t it? Though with the album firmly in my filthy hands I can see why it was the first single as it is one of the most easily accessible tracks here. We start off with another top notch bass line from La Pulga before the Swan comes in with his defiantly old school quasi-rap. The chorus was a bit jarring to me at first and seemed out of place. It still feels like that a bit but I do love the sound. The Rolling Stones vibe that Flea and every other critic in the world latched onto is in full force on that chorus. Hoffer does some tasty guitar bends and there may be enough cowbell present to even satisfy that persistent cynic Christopher Walken (keep on rockin’ Walken). Not much to say here, a good track, not essential damn it but good and sometimes that’s all you need.
Did I Let You Know: What’s this, something new? A definite Latin jazz influence is on display here, or maybe it’s a merengue influence. I’m not sure because I’m a musically ignorant bastard who only namedrops to sound knowledgable. I kind of get an Olga Tanon or Melina Leon vibe here but that’s probably due to the sever brain damage I suffered at the hands of Larry “El Longostino” Magana back in 83’. That was the match that ended my career as a professional boxer but you can never truly leave the sport behind, it’s in your blood. I’ll be a pugilist til’ the day I die. But I digress. The instrumentation is completely unique for the Pepps, which makes the song immediately stand out. The Kling’s vocals here are top notch. One of my favoritist bands in the world is The Who and a trait of theirs I always loved since I saw them play way back in the Summer of 71' is the band was never shy of allowing all the members to have a turn at vocals. Baba O’ Reilly is made even greater with Pete Townshend’s little lead part and hearing the Blade Yarder join Kiedis on the chorus in this song is a treat. The guy has a beautiful voice and I think this is only going to blossom with time. This track also has mad percussion and Flea’s trumpet ejaculating all over the place, which is always appreciated.
Goodbye Hooray: Another wonderful pop-rocker. For all the dogmatic whiners out there this is probably the closest we’ll get to a Mother’s Milk sounding track ever again. I don’t like this one quite as much as Look Around but it’s close. Flea and Klinghoffer each take a turn tearing their respective stringed instruments to shreds and it’s a Wash (great Pearl Jam b-side) as to which one I prefer. Not much to say here, a great hyperactive song.
Happiness Loves Company: This is the standout track for me right now. It definitely has an old school classic rock vibe to it but in the end sounds like a song that could only come from the Red Hot Chili Peppers. The piano is the burst of positive energy that puts it over the top and combines with AK’s vocals to create the aural equivalent of frolicking around your favorite town, picking up potential mates and partying like it’s 1999 (where the sky was all purple no less). Smith’s drumming is right in the pocket (I love throwing out musical phrases like that since I have no discernable musical talent of my own) and I so with this song was longer. I could listen to this chorus 247 times in a row and not grow tired of it.
Police Station: They played this (along with 12 of the other album’s tracks) at the aforementioned theatrically released concert and this is clearly a live anthem. This may be AK’s best vocal performance on the disc and his voice really soars in the chorus while the music expands around him, air currents of guitar, bass and drums that push his lyrics up higher. Speaking of lyrics, they are rather poetic this time. I won’t go into any analysis because this is still too fresh but they are well worth reading. The piano adds a nice eerie, touch to this track.
Even You Brutus: Many audacious claims have been made about this track with large factions calling it the best song on the album and saying that Tony Flow’s vocals are akin to Eminem or Jay-Z. I would disagree with both those claims. The verses don’t really sound like rap to me, just shouting in an almost classic rock style (a la Come Together by The Beatles). I can see some hip-hop similarities with the piano but that’s about it. Anthony’s cat like growl punctuating the chorus is a more than welcome vocalizing trick and makes me laugh with unadulterated joy every time I hear it. In fact, this whole track is top notch, Kling does some great subtle work in the chorus and Flea and Chad are as on point as ever. This is the song I will pump up in my car – both to and from work – turning the volume loud and shouting along to every word. I’ll stare at people when we’re parked side by side at the lights and sing ever more loud, daring them to look my way and say something so I can promptly exit the vehicle, pull them out through the window by the shirt collar and savagely beat them to within an inch of their worthless lives. This track is a definite standout and does not sound quite like anything else in their catalogue.
Meet at the Corner: The sequencing of this album is peculiar and it feels like the disc concludes with a series of songs that individually may be great but are each too mellow to place side by side. This song suffers due its placement (as hip as Even You Brutus is, it’s still not quite a righteous, sadistic gut punching rocker). This song is reminiscent of Hey of Stadium Arcadium. I love Hey but right now I only like this song. The chorus is stirring and the bass and guitar have a beautiful interaction but this one tends to fade into the background until the last 90 seconds or so. But that last 90 seconds is a doozy, the melody shifts and AK’s delivery shines. Hoff’s country tinged guitar solo at the end is touching with the only complaint that it is far too short. Maybe that’s the point though; surely wanting more is a sign of a job well done in this case. Still, I hope to one day visit a Parallel Universe where that solo stretches on for a lot longer.
Dance Dance Dance: And here we are at the last track of the album. Surprisingly this is not a cover of the great song by the Steve Miller Band but a teeth shatteringly dreamy original. I’m always curious to see if an artist will try and go for a big, epic, dramatic finish (Venice Queen), go for something subdued (Road Trippin’), go for something ball bashing (Johnny Kick a Hole in the Sky) or even go out on a little comical number (They’re Red Hot). Despite the plethora of choices I just left I’m not sure where this concluding track would fit in, guess I really wrote myself into a corner there, didn’t I? This is one of the best songs on the album – so says me – and is my other fave. RHCP have of a few of these super ethereal tracks – Warm Tape and Don’t Forget Me from By the Way, Animal Bar from Stadium Arcadium, Porcelain from Californication, and they are always spellbinding. I don’t think this matches my fave of Warm Tape (at least not yet) but it is an achingly gorgeous track with superb drums and bass (not to be confused with the popular electronic offshoot genre drum n’ bass, of which David Bowie did an entire album of called Earthling, oh Bowie, how you have stolen my heart). Smith’s drums during the chorus are elegant and inspired. Flea’s bass locks in and creates that dream like pastoral backdrop that leaves Anthony and Josh free to paint further with melodic ambience. Seriously, I know some are complaining that this is a weird note to end on but I could not disagree more. They’re going out on a dream note, taking you to that strange and mysterious plateau where the must is just the sound of your emotions running free. This was the PERFECT track to end on.
So there we have it, my track by track. Let us take a moment for some parting thoughts.
Something must be said about Anthony Kiedis’s lyrics here. I used to love his lyrics until I discovered…well, that will all be discussed further in the future. AK’s lyrics are clever but very often it feels like that’s all they are, with precious little behind them. This can make their songs seems shallow at times. I cannot deny his talent for wordsmithing but his style sometimes makes really connecting with a song difficult. Still, he does have several standout moments on this album and many of the disc’s most soaring choruses are made so through his contributions. His overall work on this album is good and strong but very little is surprising. His contributions are almost exactly what one would expect and I hope he can progress a bit in the future.
Flea must be voted as the MVP for this album. The face humping bass is the porn shop sticky glue that holds these 14 tracks together. I know he had a massive calloused hand in composing many of these tracks and his writing is strong throughout. He and Smith are in their finest form in years and both sound revitalized.
Speaking of Chad Smith, he does interesting work all over this album, rocking hard with tasty fills and leaving all kinds of unexpected percussive imprints. It seems Rick Rubin must have been asleep at the controls when he let some interesting drum work slip through. I have long been hoping they would use a different producer from Rick Rubin and I will continue to hope for that. Aside from track 1, this album suffers the same plight of their last few efforts: the music all exists on the same even and far too loud level. The instruments and vocals have no room to breathe and many parts that should sound incredible and dynamic are left sounding lifeless. This is not the band’s fault in any way as they are giving their all. Of course, I blew out my speakers a long time ago which could contribute to the iffy sound, hmmmm….
This finally leaves us with Josh Klinghoffer. I first became acquainted with his work way back in the summer of 76’ when I bought the John Frusciante album Shadows Collide With People on which Mr Klinghoffer played on, co-writing a couple tracks. I heard him on other Fru discs including the group they have together, Ataxia but I was never clear on what exactly he wrote and which contributions belonged to which artist. After hearing I’m With You I have no misgivings whatsoever about this man. He rises to the occasion of joining a band of this caliber, never overplaying his hand but doing great stuff all around. His sound is different, more ambient you might say, and is as refreshing as the first track. I have to question those expecting or even wanting him to be a John clone. What would be the point of that? It’s much more exciting to have a fresh voice within the band and if they continue in this configuration I believe we will be in store for some truly spectacular work.
In a bittersweet way this album has fully confirmed what I’ve known for a long time: The Chili Peppers are no longer my favorite band, nowhere near actually. Yet I still love them. I will stay play the hell out of this record and in ten or fifteen years when they release a new one I’ll be rocking out to that as well.
I still haven’t decided how I’m going to rate things. Right now, I’ll say this album is recommended with a good score of 333 stars out of a possible 408.
Everyone please feel free to leave comments, even if they are hateful and venomous (maybe especially).
Also, Ben Affleck is going to be cast as Batman in couple years. Mark my words.
Thanks for reading.